Contact

MONTAUK COLEMAN OF COMPASS

(516) 445-1513

Office

37 Carl Fisher Plz
Montauk NY 11954

Follow Us

Search
Leave a Message
Thank you for your message. We will be in touch with you shortly.
Explore Our Properties
  • Aerial view of a shingle-style home with a pool beside the ocean.
  • 523 Old Highway
  • 523 Old Highway
  • 523 Old Highway
  • 523 Old Highway
  • 523 Old Highway
  • 523 Old Highway
  • 523 Old Highway
  • 523 Old Highway
  • 523 Old Highway
  • 523 Old Highway
  • 523 Old Highway
  • 523 Old Highway
  • 523 Old Highway
  • 523 Old Highway
  • 523 Old Highway
  • 523 Old Highway
  • 523 Old Highway
  • 523 Old Highway
  • 523 Old Highway
  • 523 Old Highway
  • 523 Old Highway
  • 523 Old Highway
  • 523 Old Highway
  • 523 Old Highway
  • 523 Old Highway
  • 523 Old Highway
  • 523 Old Highway

$6,000,000

523 Old Highway, Montauk, NY 11954

  • Bedrooms

    5

  • Bathrooms

    6

  • Sq.Ft.

    3,700

Photos Map Street View
Contact Us

Property Description

This is an opportunity to own a beautiful traditional style home across the street from the ocean with a path to the sand just 100 feet away from this property. Enter the upside down style home to find an open kitchen with quartz countertops, stainless steel appliances, counter seating, and a dining area. The kitchen opens to the living room with fireplace and sliders out to the ocean facing deck. These living areas and the deck offer gorgeous views of the ocean. This level also has an office and a full bathroom. Downstairs, there are two guest bedrooms and a full bathroom along with a primary suite which has a walk-in closet and it's own private bath. Separate from this "main house" there is an attached "cottage", the original portion of the home dating back to the 1950's, where one can find two bedrooms, a full bathroom, living area, and a kitchenette. Additionally, there is a gym with a powder room, a separate room with a full bathroom, and a basement with additional space. The grounds are manicured and hedged in for privacy with a new heated gunite pool surrounded by brick terracing. Lovingly maintained by the same owners for 45+ years, this property is a prime location with plenty of space for all to enjoy.

Overview

Property Status
Sold
Date Sold
May 7, 2025
Lot Size
0.29 Acres
MLS ID
11341568
Property Type
Residential
Year Built
1960

Features & Amenities

Neighborhood
Montauk
View Description
Ocean
Stories
2
Water Source
Well
Pool
In Ground, Heated, Gunite
Heat Type
Baseboard, Propane, Electric
Appliances
Washer, Stainless Steel Appliance(s), Range, Refrigerator, Dryer, Dishwasher
Sewer
Septic Tank
School District
000000
Sales Price
$6,000,000
Zoning
Residential

Downloads

Aerial view of a shingle-style home with a pool beside the ocean.

Schedule a Tour

We would love to help you see this beautiful home! As a full-service brokerage, we can help you tour. Please submit an offer, and answer questions about the buying process.

Change time

Thank you

for your interest in 523 Old Highway, Montauk, NY 11954

523 Old Highway
Navigate
Modern wood-clad house with rooftop terraces beside a reflecting pool at dusk.

Explore Montauk

41.0359° N, 71.9545° W

read more

I'm Interested In

523 Old Highway

or
  • CallChris Coleman

    License # 40CO1097225

    (516) 445-1513

    • Browse Our

    Featured Properties

    • Aerial view of an outlined residential lot among leafy homes near the beach and ocean. For Sale

      $19,900,000

      5 Spaeth Lane, East Hampton, NY 11937

      • 6 Beds
      • 5 Baths
      • 3,700 Sq.Ft.
    • Modern gray house with rooftop solar panels, landscaped grounds, and a broad water view. For Sale

      $14,500,000

      70 Kettle Hole Road, Montauk, NY 11954

      • 6 Beds
      • 6.5 Baths
      • 6,000 Sq.Ft.
    • Oceanfront home with a swimming pool overlooking the ocean and dune grass. For Sale

      $12,995,000

      5 Oceanview Terrace, Montauk, NY 11954

      • 4 Beds
      • 5 Baths
      • 3,000 Sq.Ft.
    • Aerial view of a modern home with a pool, broad lawn, and ocean visible in the distance. For Sale

      $9,790,000

      6 Tara Road, Montauk, NY 11954

      • 4 Beds
      • 5 Baths
      • 4,000 Sq.Ft.
    • Aerial view of a white multi-wing house with rooftop solar panels and a backyard swimming pool. For Sale

      $9,495,000

      7 Ashwood Court, Amagansett, NY 11930

      • 8 Beds
      • 9.5 Baths
      • 9,070 Sq.Ft.
    • Aerial view of a waterfront home and marked lot beside a calm bay. For Sale

      $6,950,000

      278 West Lake Drive, Montauk, NY 11954

      • 4 Beds
      • 4 Baths
      • 3,575 Sq.Ft.
    • Ocean view from a balcony over coastal greenery, with a distant shoreline. For Sale

      $4,995,000

      58 Firestone Road, Montauk, NY 11954

      • 4 Beds
      • 3 Baths
      • 2,500 Sq.Ft.
    • Interior opens to a balcony with lounge chairs overlooking the beach and ocean. For Sale

      $3,950,000

      272 Old Highway, #805, Montauk, NY 11954

      • 1 Bed
      • 2 Baths
      • 1,181 Sq.Ft.
    • Aerial view of a coastal property outlined in white, with homes, beach, and ocean nearby. For Sale

      $3,700,000

      32 Ditch Plains Road, Montauk, NY 11954

      • 4 Beds
      • 3 Baths
      • 1,500 Sq.Ft.
    • Aerial view of a two-story home with a wraparound deck and spacious fenced lawn. For Sale

      $3,100,000

      20 Benson Drive, Montauk, NY 11954

      • 3 Beds
      • 2 Baths
      • 1,775 Sq.Ft.
    • Wooded dirt path leading to the water, framed by leafy trees. Active Under Contract

      $2,900,000

      6 Fort Lane, Montauk, NY 11954

    • Wood-clad modern home with a gravel driveway and landscaped courtyard beneath mature trees. For Sale

      $2,395,000

      2 Oyster Shores Road, East Hampton, NY 11937

      • 4 Beds
      • 3 Baths
      • 2,100 Sq.Ft.
    • Aerial view of an outlined residential lot among coastal homes, trees, and the ocean. Active Under Contract

      $2,395,000

      33 Agnew Avenue, Montauk, NY 11954

      • 3 Beds
      • 2 Baths
    • Dark two-story house framed by leafy trees, behind a stone wall and lawn. For Sale

      $1,950,000

      126 Fairview Avenue, Montauk, NY 11954

      • 3 Beds
      • 3 Baths
      • 2,200 Sq.Ft.
    • Wooded coastal parcel outlined in white, with nearby homes and ocean beyond. For Sale

      $1,690,000

      26 Seaside Avenue, Montauk, NY 11954

    • Aerial view of a vacant lot near the beach, outlined beside roadside buildings. For Sale

      $1,050,000

      664 Montauk Highway, Montauk, NY 11954

    • Aerial view of a wooded residential lot outlined in white beside a pond. For Sale

      $799,000

      170 Little Fresh Pond, Southampton, NY 11968

      • 2 Beds
      • 1 Bath
      • 500 Sq.Ft.
    • Aerial view of a beachfront property with a pool, tennis courts, and ocean shoreline. For Sale

      $595,000

      2178 Highway, #73, Montauk, NY 11954

      • 1 Bed
      • 1 Bath
      • 497 Sq.Ft.
    • Aerial view of a shingle-style estate with formal gardens, a pool, lagoon, and ocean beyond. For Lease

      $428,571/mo

      409 First Neck Lane, Southampton, NY 11968

      • 9 Beds
      • 8 Baths
      • 7,468 Sq.Ft.
    • Oceanfront deck with white lounge chairs overlooking a sandy beach and rolling waves. For Lease

      $200,000/mo

      272 Old Highway, Salt Sea #9, Montauk, NY 11954

      • 4 Beds
      • 5 Baths
      • 3,544 Sq.Ft.
    • Furnished seaside deck overlooking a sandy beach and ocean For Lease

      $175,000/mo

      272 Old Highway, Salt Sea #8, Montauk, NY 11954

      • 4 Beds
      • 5 Baths
      • 3,544 Sq.Ft.
    • Beachfront patio with a hot tub overlooking dune grass, sandy beach, and ocean. For Lease

      $100,000/mo

      272 Old Highway, Salt Sea #3, Montauk, NY 11954

      • 3 Beds
      • 4 Baths
      • 2,600 Sq.Ft.
    • Shingle-sided home with a second-floor balcony, garage, and curved driveway amid mature trees. For Lease

      $40,000/mo

      5 South Dorset, Montauk, NY 11954

      • 5 Beds
      • 5 Baths
      • 3,400 Sq.Ft.
    • Modern gray house with a raised deck and gravel patio surrounded by lush trees. For Lease

      $33,000/mo

      36 Hoppin Avenue, Montauk, NY 11954

      • 3 Beds
      • 3 Baths
      • 1,300 Sq.Ft.
    • Aerial view of an outlined coastal property with a small house near a sandy beach and ocean. For Lease

      $30,000/mo

      12 Jackson Road, Montauk, NY 11954

      • 1 Bed
      • 1 Bath
      • 900 Sq.Ft.
    • Single-story shingle-sided home with a covered porch, trimmed shrubs, and a broad green lawn. For Lease

      $25,714/mo

      1 Shadbush Road, Montauk, NY 11954

      • 4 Beds
      • 3 Baths
      • 2,000 Sq.Ft.
    View All Properties

    Follow Us On Instagram

    Dining room with a set table, pendant lights, and large windows overlooking greenery.

    Get in Touch

    MONTAUK COLEMAN OF COMPASS

    (516) 445-1513

    37 Carl Fisher Plz Montauk NY 11954

    Get in Touch

    Enter a valid email

    Get in Touch

    MONTAUK COLEMAN OF COMPASS

    (516) 445-1513

    37 Carl Fisher Plz Montauk NY 11954